California Arts Education Data Project Talking Points

California Arts Education Data Project Talking Points
The California Arts Education Data Project is a new tool designed to help increase participation in arts

•   
  
•   This information can help school leaders, parents and advocates determine the status of arts education access in their schools and identify and address what inequities exist.
  
•   By having a complete picture of where our secondary schools currently stand, leaders will be able to take steps to close gaps in access to a core arts education curriculum in their districts.
  Presented in a user-friendly, color-coded dashboard, the Project provides important information to education leaders, teachers and parents about levels of access to and enrollment in arts programming in schools.
  

•   The dashboard allows users to review school-level, district, county and statewide data and presents the statewide averages as the baseline for comparison.
  
•   It reports data from 2013–2014 and 2014–2015 from 3,719 schools, covering more than three million students in grades 6 through 12, which is roughly half of California’s student population.
  
•   The source of data comes directly from information schools submitted through the California Longitudinal Pupil Achievement Data System (CALPADS) - California’s K–12 longitudinal data system.
  
•   As California elementary schools are not required to report subject-level data, information on arts education in grades pre-k through 5 is not currently included.
  The Data Project also features A Roadmap for School Districts that guides leaders through the process of examining their data to better understand their unique circumstances and challenges.
  

•   The Roadmap contains resources and helpful guides to assist districts in assessing their own programs and creating strategic arts plans.
  
•   The Data Project also provides a communication toolkit that includes materials to share these new resources with local stakeholders.
  Quality arts education sparks creative thinking and sets up students for success in college, career and life.
  

 These important tools will provide a complete picture of where California’s schools currently stand, allowing leaders to ensure their schools can provide invaluable arts education to every child in California. 

California Arts Education Data Project Talking Points

California Arts Education Data Project Talking Points
The California Arts Education Data Project is a new tool designed to help increase participation in arts

•   
  
•   This information can help school leaders, parents and advocates determine the status of arts education access in their schools and identify and address what inequities exist.
  
•   By having a complete picture of where our secondary schools currently stand, leaders will be able to take steps to close gaps in access to a core arts education curriculum in their districts.
  Presented in a user-friendly, color-coded dashboard, the Project provides important information to education leaders, teachers and parents about levels of access to and enrollment in arts programming in schools.
  

•   The dashboard allows users to review school-level, district, county and statewide data and presents the statewide averages as the baseline for comparison.
  
•   It reports data from 2013–2014 and 2014–2015 from 3,719 schools, covering more than three million students in grades 6 through 12, which is roughly half of California’s student population.
  
•   The source of data comes directly from information schools submitted through the California Longitudinal Pupil Achievement Data System (CALPADS) - California’s K–12 longitudinal data system.
  
•   As California elementary schools are not required to report subject-level data, information on arts education in grades pre-k through 5 is not currently included.
  The Data Project also features A Roadmap for School Districts that guides leaders through the process of examining their data to better understand their unique circumstances and challenges.
  

•   The Roadmap contains resources and helpful guides to assist districts in assessing their own programs and creating strategic arts plans.
  
•   The Data Project also provides a communication toolkit that includes materials to share these new resources with local stakeholders.
  Quality arts education sparks creative thinking and sets up students for success in college, career and life.
  

 These important tools will provide a complete picture of where California’s schools currently stand, allowing leaders to ensure their schools can provide invaluable arts education to every child in California. 

California Arts Education Data Project FAQs

The California Arts Education Data Project FAQs
Q1: What is the California Arts Education Data Project? A: The California Arts Education Data Project is
Presented in a user-friendly, color-coded dashboard, the Project provides important information to education leaders, teachers and parents about levels of access to and
enrollment in arts programming in schools. The dashboard allows users to review school-level, district, county and statewide data and presents the statewide averages as the baseline for comparison. The executive summary and dashboard report data from 2013–2014 and 2014–2015 from 3,719 schools, covering more than three million students in grades 6 through 12 which is roughly half of California’s student population.
Q2: Why is the Data Project important?
A: The Data Project responds to the need the 2015 Blueprint for Creative Schools identified for better collection of data on access and equity in arts education. The Data Project provides leaders at the state, district and school level – as well as parents and advocates – with the information they need to determine the status of arts education access and what inequities exist. Ultimately, by having a complete picture of where California’s secondary schools currently stand, leaders will be able to take steps to close gaps in access to a core arts education curriculum in their districts.
Q3. Who is involved with the Data Project?
A: Create CA and the California Department of Education are launching the Data Project as part of the Arts Education Data Project, a national effort led by the State Education Agency Directors of Arts Education and Quadrant Research to collect and analyze arts education data in coordination with state departments of education. California is in the first cohort for 2016, along with North Carolina, Ohio and Wisconsin. An additional 10 states will be joining the project in 2017.
Along with the Data Project, the organizations are releasing The California Arts Education Data Project: A Roadmap for School Districts to guide districts through the process of examining their data to better understand their unique circumstances and challenges. The Roadmap contains resources and helpful guides to assist districts in assessing their own programs and creating strategic arts plans. In addition, they are releasing the

designed to increase participation in arts education

across the state

by

analyzing and reporting school-level data on arts education courses and middle and

high school enrollment across the state.

California Arts Education Data Project Communication Toolkit, which provides

materials to share these new resources with local stakeholders.

1

Q4: How was data obtained for this project?
A: The source of data comes directly from information schools submitted through the California Longitudinal Pupil Achievement Data System (CALPADS) - California’s K–12 longitudinal data system for the 2013–2014 and the 2014–2015 school years. The project reports on student enrollment in arts education courses for schools with grades 6 through 12, which includes high schools, intermediate/middle/junior high schools and elementary/high combinations schools. As a result, the report covers 3,719 schools with a total population of 3,070,640 students. Demographic data is from the Common Core of Data file from the National Center for Education Statistics. Data will be added annually, allowing the project to show progress over time.
Q5: Does the effort include arts education data from elementary schools?
A: As California elementary schools are not required to report subject-level data, information on arts
education in grades pre-k through 5 is currently not included.
Q6: How are private schools and charter schools reflected in the data?
A: Private schools are not required to report to California’s K–12 longitudinal data system and therefore are not included in the data. Charter schools are public schools, and thus are required to report data and are included in the project.
Q7: What is the process for registering new information if we discover that our arts data has changed?
The data displayed is taken directly from CALPADS. If you have any questions about your data, we recommend you start by examining how you assigned your course codes. New data for the 2015–2016 year was recently submitted, so this is the perfect time to make sure course codes are correct and that your arts offerings are properly reflected.
Q8: What does the Data Project tell us about arts education in California?
A: The data reinforces the need to continue to address inequities in access to and participation in arts education. The data shows the greater the percentage of students receiving free and reduced lunch, the lower the participation rate in the arts. In addition, the data indicates that the proportion of students without access to any arts courses was higher where the majority of students in the school are either African American or Hispanic when compared to the total student enrollment distribution. This underscores how access to arts education is directly linked to fundamental inequities in our education system.

2

Q9: Why aren’t more students taking arts education courses even when they are available in their schools?
A: There are many potential reasons why students may not be enrolling in available arts courses that map to each school’s unique student population, school environment and course offerings. Districts should consider forming a data team to take a closer look at the data and what factors might be challenges for student enrollment.
Some possible factors to consider include:

•   Guidance counselors may not be aware of the growing creative workforce and may be advising students not to sign up for arts education courses;
  
•   Due to limited class availability and scheduling, students may be unable to fit the desired arts programs into their school day;
  
•   Students may be unable to take electives because of more intensive math and language arts requirements; and
  
•   Students may feel unskilled and intimidated if arts education courses were missing or limited in their elementary schools.
  Q10: What does enrollment in rural or small schools tell us about the challenges they face?
  A: School districts in rural communities are more likely to have smaller enrollment sizes and fewer resources, which often translate into fewer course offerings. However, rural districts could work around these challenges by using a shared services model in which arts teachers are shared among schools and among districts. Rural districts could also consider distance learning options.
  Q11: What historic factors have contributed to the decline of arts education in California’s public schools?
  A combination of national and statewide actions led to a decline in arts education in California’s public schools over the past forty years. In 1970, California passed the Ryan Act, which eliminated training in arts education instruction from the requirements of the multi-subject teaching credential. This change opened the door for the next generation of elementary school teachers to enter the classroom, unprepared to deliver arts education instruction to elementary school students. In 1978, nearly two- thirds of California’s voters passed Proposition 13, reducing property tax rates on homes, businesses and farms by approximately 57% and causing districts to cut back on budgets. Arts education was one of the hardest hit areas. In 2002, President George W. Bush signed the No Child Left Behind Act into law, which narrowed the focus of schools on literacy and math, further isolating arts education from the core curriculum that schools are required to provide. It provided the justification for districts to cut programs in the arts, which were not often seen as directly benefiting student success. Last, the California budget crisis stripped funding for arts education in 2008 as districts scrambled to make ends meet with fewer resources.
  

3

Q12: What funders support this effort?
Create CA is funded through the generous support of The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, The National Endowment for the Arts, The Stuart Foundation, The Music Man Foundation, The California Arts Council and The Panta Rhea Foundation. The Arts Education Data Project is funded through the generous support of The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, NAMM Foundation, Ohio Arts Council, Educational Theatre Association and National Association for Music Education.

4 

The Arts Data Project Frequently Asked Questions

The California Arts Education Data Project FAQs
Q1: What is the California Arts Education Data Project? A: The California Arts Education Data Project is
Presented in a user-friendly, color-coded dashboard, the Project provides important information to education leaders, teachers and parents about levels of access to and
enrollment in arts programming in schools. The dashboard allows users to review school-level, district, county and statewide data and presents the statewide averages as the baseline for comparison. The executive summary and dashboard report data from 2013–2014 and 2014–2015 from 3,719 schools, covering more than three million students in grades 6 through 12 which is roughly half of California’s student population.
Q2: Why is the Data Project important?
A: The Data Project responds to the need the 2015 Blueprint for Creative Schools identified for better collection of data on access and equity in arts education. The Data Project provides leaders at the state, district and school level – as well as parents and advocates – with the information they need to determine the status of arts education access and what inequities exist. Ultimately, by having a complete picture of where California’s secondary schools currently stand, leaders will be able to take steps to close gaps in access to a core arts education curriculum in their districts.
Q3. Who is involved with the Data Project?
A: Create CA and the California Department of Education are launching the Data Project as part of the Arts Education Data Project, a national effort led by the State Education Agency Directors of Arts Education and Quadrant Research to collect and analyze arts education data in coordination with state departments of education. California is in the first cohort for 2016, along with North Carolina, Ohio and Wisconsin. An additional 10 states will be joining the project in 2017.
Along with the Data Project, the organizations are releasing The California Arts Education Data Project: A Roadmap for School Districts to guide districts through the process of examining their data to better understand their unique circumstances and challenges. The Roadmap contains resources and helpful guides to assist districts in assessing their own programs and creating strategic arts plans. In addition, they are releasing the

designed to increase participation in arts education

across the state

by

analyzing and reporting school-level data on arts education courses and middle and

high school enrollment across the state.

California Arts Education Data Project Communication Toolkit, which provides

materials to share these new resources with local stakeholders.

1

Q4: How was data obtained for this project?
A: The source of data comes directly from information schools submitted through the California Longitudinal Pupil Achievement Data System (CALPADS) - California’s K–12 longitudinal data system for the 2013–2014 and the 2014–2015 school years. The project reports on student enrollment in arts education courses for schools with grades 6 through 12, which includes high schools, intermediate/middle/junior high schools and elementary/high combinations schools. As a result, the report covers 3,719 schools with a total population of 3,070,640 students. Demographic data is from the Common Core of Data file from the National Center for Education Statistics. Data will be added annually, allowing the project to show progress over time.
Q5: Does the effort include arts education data from elementary schools?
A: As California elementary schools are not required to report subject-level data, information on arts
education in grades pre-k through 5 is currently not included.
Q6: How are private schools and charter schools reflected in the data?
A: Private schools are not required to report to California’s K–12 longitudinal data system and therefore are not included in the data. Charter schools are public schools, and thus are required to report data and are included in the project.
Q7: What is the process for registering new information if we discover that our arts data has changed?
The data displayed is taken directly from CALPADS. If you have any questions about your data, we recommend you start by examining how you assigned your course codes. New data for the 2015–2016 year was recently submitted, so this is the perfect time to make sure course codes are correct and that your arts offerings are properly reflected.
Q8: What does the Data Project tell us about arts education in California?
A: The data reinforces the need to continue to address inequities in access to and participation in arts education. The data shows the greater the percentage of students receiving free and reduced lunch, the lower the participation rate in the arts. In addition, the data indicates that the proportion of students without access to any arts courses was higher where the majority of students in the school are either African American or Hispanic when compared to the total student enrollment distribution. This underscores how access to arts education is directly linked to fundamental inequities in our education system.

2

Q9: Why aren’t more students taking arts education courses even when they are available in their schools?
A: There are many potential reasons why students may not be enrolling in available arts courses that map to each school’s unique student population, school environment and course offerings. Districts should consider forming a data team to take a closer look at the data and what factors might be challenges for student enrollment.
Some possible factors to consider include:

•   Guidance counselors may not be aware of the growing creative workforce and may be advising students not to sign up for arts education courses;
  
•   Due to limited class availability and scheduling, students may be unable to fit the desired arts programs into their school day;
  
•   Students may be unable to take electives because of more intensive math and language arts requirements; and
  
•   Students may feel unskilled and intimidated if arts education courses were missing or limited in their elementary schools.
  Q10: What does enrollment in rural or small schools tell us about the challenges they face?
  A: School districts in rural communities are more likely to have smaller enrollment sizes and fewer resources, which often translate into fewer course offerings. However, rural districts could work around these challenges by using a shared services model in which arts teachers are shared among schools and among districts. Rural districts could also consider distance learning options.
  Q11: What historic factors have contributed to the decline of arts education in California’s public schools?
  A combination of national and statewide actions led to a decline in arts education in California’s public schools over the past forty years. In 1970, California passed the Ryan Act, which eliminated training in arts education instruction from the requirements of the multi-subject teaching credential. This change opened the door for the next generation of elementary school teachers to enter the classroom, unprepared to deliver arts education instruction to elementary school students. In 1978, nearly two- thirds of California’s voters passed Proposition 13, reducing property tax rates on homes, businesses and farms by approximately 57% and causing districts to cut back on budgets. Arts education was one of the hardest hit areas. In 2002, President George W. Bush signed the No Child Left Behind Act into law, which narrowed the focus of schools on literacy and math, further isolating arts education from the core curriculum that schools are required to provide. It provided the justification for districts to cut programs in the arts, which were not often seen as directly benefiting student success. Last, the California budget crisis stripped funding for arts education in 2008 as districts scrambled to make ends meet with fewer resources.
  

3

Q12: What funders support this effort?
Create CA is funded through the generous support of The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, The National Endowment for the Arts, The Stuart Foundation, The Music Man Foundation, The California Arts Council and The Panta Rhea Foundation. The Arts Education Data Project is funded through the generous support of The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, NAMM Foundation, Ohio Arts Council, Educational Theatre Association and National Association for Music Education.

4 

For Immediate Release:
October 20, 2016

Arts Advocates Launch New Suite of Tools to Help Schools and Communities 
Improve Status of Arts Education Throughout the State

Tools designed to identify and help address education inequities across the state
Sacramento, CA – Create CA, in partnership with the California Department of Education and the Arts Education Data Project, first-of-its-kind grades 6 through 12
– as well as parents and advocates –today launched a suite of tools designed to help increase participation in arts education across the state. The California Arts Education Data Project: A Roadmap for School Districts guides districts through the process of examining their data to better understand their unique circumstances and challenges.

The tools include the California Arts Education Data Project, which analyzes and reports school-level

data on arts education courses and enrollment across the state. It is designed to enable leaders at the state, district and school level address education inequities across the state. In addition, to identify and

understand their unique circumstances and challenges. The Roadmap contains resources and helpful guides to assist districts in assessing their own programs and creating strategic arts plans. Finally, the
“School leaders want to offer diverse and high-quality arts education courses, which are essential to ensuring our students foster the creativity needed for 21st century careers,” said State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson. “We know arts education in California isn’t where we want it to be and we’re excited to join with our partners to provide new tools to help connect school leaders with other districts to learn best practices and strategies for navigating challenges.”

Presented in a user-friendly, color-coded dashboard, the Project provides important information to education leaders, teachers and parents about levels of access to and enrollment in arts programming in schools. The dashboard allows users to review school-level, district, county and statewide data and presents the statewide averages as the baseline for comparison. It reports data from 2013–2014 and 2014–2015 from 3,719 schools, covering more than three million students in grades 6 through 12, which is roughly half of California’s student population.

“Quality arts education has long been lauded as an important priority in California because we know it sparks creative thinking, an essential skill to succeed in today’s competitive workforce,” said Craig Cheslog, chair elect of Create CA, California’s Statewide Arts Education Coalition. “But as our 2015 Blueprint for Creative Schools identified, until now there have been few opportunities to analyze arts education data in a coordinated effort to identify and help address education inequities at the secondary school level.”

California Arts Education Data Project Communication Toolkit provides materials to share these new

resources with local stakeholders.

The executive summary of the data show that although nearly 97 percent of students have access to some level of arts education, 26 percent of students have access to all four arts disciplines of dance, music, theatre and visual art as required by the state education code. Also, 86 percent of schools provide at least one arts discipline, but only 12 percent of schools offer the four required arts disciplines. The data shows the need to improve student participation rates, as only 38 percent of students were enrolled in at least one arts discipline. Further disparities exist by discipline, with 17 percent of students enrolled in art, 14 percent in music, 5 percent in arts, media and entertainment, 4 percent in theatre and 2 percent in dance.
“Data is an important tool to improve outcomes,” said Bob Morrison of Quadrant Research, the Arts Education Data Project’s research partner and project director. “In New Jersey, we saw that just the act of making arts education data available to schools led to increased participation rates, and we have high hopes for California.”

The data reinforces the need to continue to address inequities in access to and participation in arts education. The data shows the greater the percentage of students on free and reduced lunch, the lower the arts participation rate. In addition, the data indicates that the proportion of students without access to any arts courses was greater where the majority of students in the school are either African American or Hispanic when compared to the total student enrollment distribution.
Research Findings Summary (see full research summary results here)

•   Between 2014 and 2015, there was a 9.6 percent decline in the number of students without
  access to any arts instruction.
  
•   Although nearly 97 percent of students have access to some level of arts education, only 26 percent of students have access to all four arts disciplines of dance, music, theatre and visual art as required by the state education code. Also, although 86 percent of schools provide at least one arts discipline, only 12 percent of schools offer the four required arts disciplines.
  
•   In total, 38 percent of students were enrolled in at least one arts discipline. Further disparities exist by discipline, with 17 percent of students enrolled in art, 14 percent in music, 5 percent in arts, media and entertainment, 4 percent in theatre and 2 percent in dance.
  
•   The data shows the greater the percentage of students receiving free and reduced lunch, the lower the participation rate in the arts.
  
•   The data shows the proportion of students without access to any arts courses was greater where the majority of students in the school are either African American or Hispanic when compared to the total student enrollment distribution.
  
•   Students with no access to the arts were overrepresented in charter schools.
  
•   Although schools with no arts courses tend to be in rural areas, the greatest concentration of students without access to arts is in large cities.
  

2

•   Student enrollment in arts education during middle school was unusually low. In other states arts education participation rates decline as the grade levels advance, but in California there was a larger percentage of students participating in high schools than in either middle schools or elementary/high school combination schools.
  
•   The overall student to arts teacher ratio in traditional public schools was 232 to 1. About the Data
  The California Arts Education Data Project reports on student enrollment in arts education courses for schools with grades 6 through 12, which includes high schools, intermediate/middle/junior high schools and elementary/high combinations schools. Currently, elementary school data is not included, as subject-level data is not currently collected at the elementary level. As a result, the report covers 3,719 schools with a total population of 3,070,640 students. The source of data comes directly from information schools submitted through the California Longitudinal Pupil Achievement Data System (CALPADS) - California’s K–12 longitudinal data system for the 2013–2014 and the 2014–2015 school years. Demographic data is from the Common Core of Data file from the National Center for Education Statistics. Data will be added annually, allowing the project to show progress over time.
  ###
  About Create CA
  Create CA, California’s Statewide Arts Education Coalition, is working to ensure all students are able to reach their full potential by advancing an education model that promotes creativity and the arts for the 21st century workforce. The California Department of Education, California County Superintendents Educational Services Association (CCSESA), the California Alliance for Arts Education (CAAE), the California Arts Council (CAC) and the California State PTA are organizational members coordinating with this effort. To see a complete list of the 15 members of the Create CA Leadership Council, go here.
  Create CA thanks the following funders for their generous support: The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, The National Endowment for the Arts, The Stuart Foundation, The Music Man Foundation, The California Arts Council and The Panta Rhea Foundation.
  About the California Department of Education
  The California Department of Education is a state agency led by State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson. For more information, please visit the California Department of Education’s Web site or by mobile device. You may also follow Superintendent Torlakson on Twitter, Facebook and YouTube.
  About the Arts Education Data Project
  The Arts Education Data Project is a partnership between the State Education Agency Directors of Arts Education and Quadrant Research. The nationwide project coordinates with participating state departments of education to collect and report arts education data from State Longitudinal Data
  

3

Systems (SLDS) and other state department of education data sets on an annual basis. Learn more at http://artseddata.org.
Funding for the Arts Education Data Project has been generously provided by The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, NAMM Foundation, Ohio Arts Council, Educational Theatre Association and National Association for Music Education.

4 

For Immediate Release:
October 20, 2016

Arts Advocates Launch New Suite of Tools to Help Schools and Communities 
Improve Status of Arts Education Throughout the State

Tools designed to identify and help address education inequities across the state
Sacramento, CA – Create CA, in partnership with the California Department of Education and the Arts Education Data Project, first-of-its-kind grades 6 through 12
– as well as parents and advocates –today launched a suite of tools designed to help increase participation in arts education across the state. The California Arts Education Data Project: A Roadmap for School Districts guides districts through the process of examining their data to better understand their unique circumstances and challenges.

The tools include the California Arts Education Data Project, which analyzes and reports school-level

data on arts education courses and enrollment across the state. It is designed to enable leaders at the state, district and school level address education inequities across the state. In addition, to identify and

understand their unique circumstances and challenges. The Roadmap contains resources and helpful guides to assist districts in assessing their own programs and creating strategic arts plans. Finally, the
“School leaders want to offer diverse and high-quality arts education courses, which are essential to ensuring our students foster the creativity needed for 21st century careers,” said State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson. “We know arts education in California isn’t where we want it to be and we’re excited to join with our partners to provide new tools to help connect school leaders with other districts to learn best practices and strategies for navigating challenges.”

Presented in a user-friendly, color-coded dashboard, the Project provides important information to education leaders, teachers and parents about levels of access to and enrollment in arts programming in schools. The dashboard allows users to review school-level, district, county and statewide data and presents the statewide averages as the baseline for comparison. It reports data from 2013–2014 and 2014–2015 from 3,719 schools, covering more than three million students in grades 6 through 12, which is roughly half of California’s student population.

“Quality arts education has long been lauded as an important priority in California because we know it sparks creative thinking, an essential skill to succeed in today’s competitive workforce,” said Craig Cheslog, chair elect of Create CA, California’s Statewide Arts Education Coalition. “But as our 2015 Blueprint for Creative Schools identified, until now there have been few opportunities to analyze arts education data in a coordinated effort to identify and help address education inequities at the secondary school level.”

California Arts Education Data Project Communication Toolkit provides materials to share these new

resources with local stakeholders.

The executive summary of the data show that although nearly 97 percent of students have access to some level of arts education, 26 percent of students have access to all four arts disciplines of dance, music, theatre and visual art as required by the state education code. Also, 86 percent of schools provide at least one arts discipline, but only 12 percent of schools offer the four required arts disciplines. The data shows the need to improve student participation rates, as only 38 percent of students were enrolled in at least one arts discipline. Further disparities exist by discipline, with 17 percent of students enrolled in art, 14 percent in music, 5 percent in arts, media and entertainment, 4 percent in theatre and 2 percent in dance.
“Data is an important tool to improve outcomes,” said Bob Morrison of Quadrant Research, the Arts Education Data Project’s research partner and project director. “In New Jersey, we saw that just the act of making arts education data available to schools led to increased participation rates, and we have high hopes for California.”

The data reinforces the need to continue to address inequities in access to and participation in arts education. The data shows the greater the percentage of students on free and reduced lunch, the lower the arts participation rate. In addition, the data indicates that the proportion of students without access to any arts courses was greater where the majority of students in the school are either African American or Hispanic when compared to the total student enrollment distribution.
Research Findings Summary (see full research summary results here)

•   Between 2014 and 2015, there was a 9.6 percent decline in the number of students without
  access to any arts instruction.
  
•   Although nearly 97 percent of students have access to some level of arts education, only 26 percent of students have access to all four arts disciplines of dance, music, theatre and visual art as required by the state education code. Also, although 86 percent of schools provide at least one arts discipline, only 12 percent of schools offer the four required arts disciplines.
  
•   In total, 38 percent of students were enrolled in at least one arts discipline. Further disparities exist by discipline, with 17 percent of students enrolled in art, 14 percent in music, 5 percent in arts, media and entertainment, 4 percent in theatre and 2 percent in dance.
  
•   The data shows the greater the percentage of students receiving free and reduced lunch, the lower the participation rate in the arts.
  
•   The data shows the proportion of students without access to any arts courses was greater where the majority of students in the school are either African American or Hispanic when compared to the total student enrollment distribution.
  
•   Students with no access to the arts were overrepresented in charter schools.
  
•   Although schools with no arts courses tend to be in rural areas, the greatest concentration of students without access to arts is in large cities.
  

2

•   Student enrollment in arts education during middle school was unusually low. In other states arts education participation rates decline as the grade levels advance, but in California there was a larger percentage of students participating in high schools than in either middle schools or elementary/high school combination schools.
  
•   The overall student to arts teacher ratio in traditional public schools was 232 to 1. About the Data
  The California Arts Education Data Project reports on student enrollment in arts education courses for schools with grades 6 through 12, which includes high schools, intermediate/middle/junior high schools and elementary/high combinations schools. Currently, elementary school data is not included, as subject-level data is not currently collected at the elementary level. As a result, the report covers 3,719 schools with a total population of 3,070,640 students. The source of data comes directly from information schools submitted through the California Longitudinal Pupil Achievement Data System (CALPADS) - California’s K–12 longitudinal data system for the 2013–2014 and the 2014–2015 school years. Demographic data is from the Common Core of Data file from the National Center for Education Statistics. Data will be added annually, allowing the project to show progress over time.
  ###
  About Create CA
  Create CA, California’s Statewide Arts Education Coalition, is working to ensure all students are able to reach their full potential by advancing an education model that promotes creativity and the arts for the 21st century workforce. The California Department of Education, California County Superintendents Educational Services Association (CCSESA), the California Alliance for Arts Education (CAAE), the California Arts Council (CAC) and the California State PTA are organizational members coordinating with this effort. To see a complete list of the 15 members of the Create CA Leadership Council, go here.
  Create CA thanks the following funders for their generous support: The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, The National Endowment for the Arts, The Stuart Foundation, The Music Man Foundation, The California Arts Council and The Panta Rhea Foundation.
  About the California Department of Education
  The California Department of Education is a state agency led by State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson. For more information, please visit the California Department of Education’s Web site or by mobile device. You may also follow Superintendent Torlakson on Twitter, Facebook and YouTube.
  About the Arts Education Data Project
  The Arts Education Data Project is a partnership between the State Education Agency Directors of Arts Education and Quadrant Research. The nationwide project coordinates with participating state departments of education to collect and report arts education data from State Longitudinal Data
  

3

Systems (SLDS) and other state department of education data sets on an annual basis. Learn more at http://artseddata.org.
Funding for the Arts Education Data Project has been generously provided by The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, NAMM Foundation, Ohio Arts Council, Educational Theatre Association and National Association for Music Education.

4